With the rise of generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and Claude, clients understandably look for ways to use these tools to save time and money. Relying on AI-generated contracts, however, can be riskier—and more expensive—than expected.
Although AI can produce polished-looking documents, professional presentation does not guarantee legal accuracy. The quality of its output depends heavily on the prompt, the information supplied, and the sources available to the system. Without legal training or specialized experience, a user may not know which information to ask for, recognize how contract provisions interact within the document’s overall framework, properly include defined terms, or recognize how industry-specific objectives should shape the agreement. Failing to include routine boilerplate clauses can also have significant commercial consequences when omitted or poorly drafted.
These risks extend beyond drafting quality. Generative AI produces responses based on patterns in data, which may include unreliable or outdated information. Its output is not necessarily a verified statement of fact or law. An AI-generated document may rely on outdated law, confuse legislative proposals with enacted legislation, overlook adverse court decisions, miss jurisdictional distinctions or industry practices, or cite nonexistent authority. Identifying and correcting these problems can require a line-by-line legal review, potentially costing as much as—or more than—drafting an appropriate agreement from the outset. Errors left uncorrected may also lead to costly disputes or litigation.
Confidentiality presents a separate concern. Information provided to generative AI tools may create disclosure risks, and AI conversations are not automatically protected by attorney-client privilege or the work-product doctrine. Whether those protections apply depends on various circumstances. Sharing independently generated AI materials with counsel afterward does not, by itself, make them privileged or otherwise protected from disclosure.
For these reasons, collaborating with a qualified attorney remains the best approach to preparing contracts that reflect the parties’ goals and address legal and business risks. AI can assist with the process, but it is no substitute for an attorney’s judgment and experience.
(This blog, prepared by Campanella Law Office, is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to convey specific legal advice, nor is it intended to create or constitute an attorney-client relationship.)